Discover 52 Stafford. Hotel, Restaurant & Irish Pub, a 4.3-star historic Irish-themed hotel in downtown Plymouth, WI. Enjoy warm hospitality, gourmet breakfast, live Irish music, and charming rooms with free Wi-Fi, parking, and a welcoming pub atmosphere
Visitors appreciate the warm atmosphere, attentive service, and authentic Irish pub experience, making this Victorian-style guesthouse a standout choice for a unique stay in downtown Plymouth.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
52 Stafford. Hotel, Restaurant & Irish Pub stands as a warm beacon of charm and hospitality in the heart of Plymouth, Wisconsin. With a commendable rating of 4.3, this historic establishment, originally built in the late 1800s, offers far more than just lodging—it invites guests into an authentic Irish experience woven through its rooms, restaurant, and lively pub atmosphere.
Visitors immediately sense the genuine warmth of the owners and staff, who bring a gracious and personal touch to every interaction. From the moment of check-in, where new employees like Donna greet guests with sweet congeniality, to the attentive care provided throughout a stay, 52 Stafford feels like a home away from home. This connection extends seamlessly into their thoughtfully designed spaces. The large gathering areas boast exquisite woodwork, stained glass windows, and elegant chandeliers, crafting a vintage yet inviting ambiance that resonates deeply with anyone seeking comfort mixed with character.
Of particular note is the culinary experience. The breakfast alone has been described by several guests as a standout feature—served with finesse, including coffee in sterling silver tumblers—and promising a delectable start to any day. Dinner menus present rich, complex flavors that transcend expectations, speaking to the chef’s dedication and skill in crafting a memorable meal. The on-site Irish pub adds a vibrant dimension, where live traditional music fills the air and an expertly curated drink selection complements the convivial setting. This combination captures the essence of Irish hospitality while grounding guests in the local culture of Plymouth.
Families and travelers alike appreciate the thoughtful amenities including free Wi-Fi, complimentary breakfast, and ample parking, with a welcoming environment for children. The absence of a pool or fitness center does not detract from its appeal but rather underscores its focus on authentic, relaxed experiences centered around culture, food, and community.
Set just two blocks from the Plymouth Arts Center and a short stroll from the Sheboygan County Fairgrounds, 52 Stafford offers a perfect base for exploring local attractions. The town’s quaintness further enriches a stay here, offering visitors a peaceful retreat infused with historical charm and modern comforts.
In essence, 52 Stafford is more than a hotel; it’s a heartfelt invitation to experience genuine Irish hospitality steeped in history and vibrant with life. Its unwavering commitment to personalized service, exquisite food, and immersive ambiance makes it a memorable destination that beckons guests to return again and again.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Wow what an absolutely fabulous place; the owners are incredibly hospitable, gracious, and fun – they made our stay very memorable. we really enjoyed speaking with Donna, a new employee, while we were checking in, she was so sweet & charming and made us feel immediately at home. And holy cow, the breakfast amenity exceeds all expectations and was by far the highlight of our weekend. We enjoyed ourselves so much Friday night, we recommended the stay to another couple who drove up Saturday night. We will be recommending this place to anyone looking for a unique, romantic B&B!
What a lovely experience! This is much more than just a Bed and Breakfast! Since it was built as a hotel in the late 1800's, you are welcomed into this very large gathering place with couches, chairs, dinning tables and then a beautiful bar in its own area! The glass windows, woodwork, chandeliers, etc are all amazing. The breakfast was amazing with coffee served to your table in sterling silver teapots. The vintage detail was so authentic. But, it was the staff that tied it all together. The owner stopped to say hi as we were having dessert and a drink in the bar, the cook came to say hi after breakfast, and the servers were so personable. We are from the Twin Cities area and are certainly looking for a reason to come back and stay again. It would be a grand place to spend more time at relaxing to enjoying the vintage experience. Do plan to have dinner there also!
Wednesday was a great day to step into this beautiful irish pub and hotel. This was my first time and I was blown away by the coziness and hospitality. The staff made me feel welcome, the food was amazing and the live Irish music was phenomenal. I didn't need a room for the night but I bet those are well maintained and vintage like everything else throughout the hotel. I definitely will be back for another wonderful experience.
This place is AWESOME! My husband and I went there a few weeks ago for a weekend get away, and this b&b is so charming, service is great, the little town is so cute. The chef prepared us an absolutely delicious tasting menu. The rooms were very clean and the property was just beautifully maintained. Everything was absolutely perfect, and we are trying to get all our friends to go here. Cannot recommend highly enough! Thank you!
This place is amazing!!! Way beyond my expectations. Patrick, Ronna, and the rest of the staff who I wish I remembered all their names, you guys are awesome, friendly, and so very welcoming!!!! My wife , my baby boy and I had an excellent time here . Everyone there was so nice especially to my 6 month old son. The food was amazing we had breakfast and dinner there a couple times during our stay and it was all so very delicious!! The hotel looks very nice inside and out. We will definitely be staying here next time we are in town. "Patrick please open a restaurant in the Chicago area, your dishes are amazing!"
For starters the owners were amazing. Ronna offered to help carry our things up to the room, and they were very friendly and personable. Next the rooms were very nice and comfortable. It had a very rustic feel and the beds were very comfortable. The food was absolutely amazing and it had a complexity I wasn't expecting at all. Honestly the food was better than my palate could even tell. The breakfast had subtle flavor combinations that I have never had before. Overall it was an amazing stay at a fantastic inn.
Set in downtown, this quaint Iris-themed guesthouse and pub is 2 blocks from Plymouth Arts Center, and a 15-minute walk from Sheboygan County Fairgrounds.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
4,873 reviews N 7390 WI-67, Plymouth, WI 53073, United States
596 reviews 1111 W Riverside Dr, Kohler, WI 53044, United States
69 reviews 520 E Mill St, Plymouth, WI 53073, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Luxury Inn Motel offers a 3.5star experience with clean rooms, secure parking, and free WiFi. Enjoy friendly service and a conve...
Discover Riverview Inn, a clean, quiet motel along the Caloosahatchee River in North Fort Myers. Enjoy free WiFi, ample parking, ...
Western Skies Motel offers clean, cozy rooms with free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly comfort near local attractions. Enjoy frie...
Experience friendly service and cozy rooms at Ctowninnandsuites in Cleveland, MS. Ideal for business travelers and visitors, enjoy...
Discover Crystal Motel, a clean and quiet 3.8star hotel on West Skelly Drive, Tulsa. Enjoy free WiFi, free parking, airconditio...
Fireside Inn Ely, Nevada offers clean, spacious rooms with free WiFi and parking in a quiet setting. Enjoy friendly service, pet...
Experience a welcoming stay at Coral Roc Motel, Florida City. Enjoy free parking, a sparkling outdoor pool, petfriendly and kidf...
Augusta Motel offers reliable lodging with essential business amenities in Mt Sidney, VA. Enjoy scenic sightseeing and easy access...
Experience breathtaking mountain views and familyfriendly comfort at Bear Paw Lodge in Avon, Colorado. Enjoy free WiFi, outdoor ...
Enjoy a clean, affordable stay at Countryside Inn & Suites in Council Bluffs, IA. Features free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and eas...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
